Pirates, including the notorious Captain William Kidd, are said to
have roamed the lands of Monmouth County.
One legend says that Captain Kidd buried his treasure by a huge pine
tree on Sandy Hook, but neither the treasure nor the tree has ever been
found.
Captain Kidd initially had the King's permission to arrest pirates, but
in 1697, instead of hunting them down, he joined them and began to capture
trading vessels.
He was arrested in July of 1699, sent to England for trial, and found
guilty of murder and piracy. On May 23, 1701, he was hanged.
History relates that in 1736, William Leeds, reputedly a reformed
follower of Captain Kidd, left a glebe (land yielding revenue to a church) to
be shared by CHRIST CHURCH IN SHREWSBURY and CHRIST CHURCH IN MIDDLETOWN,
then united as one church.
The present Christ Episcopal Church, at the junction of Kings Highway
and Middletown - Lincroft Road, was built in 1835, and in 1854 an act of the
state legislature separated it from the Shrewsbury church.
The Middletown church, which has been placed on the National Register of
Historic Places, preserves a romantic bit of history. In the plaster above
the pulpit is a cross, said to have been inscribed there by Captain Kidd with
the point of his sword.